How to play

  1. Start a recording in the app with a would you rather set loaded.
  2. Read the prompt above your head out loud so viewers get the dilemma too.
  3. Pick one, say why in five words or less, then rate the dilemma 1 to 10.
  4. Keep the best six reactions and post the clip as one take.

Classic dilemmas

  • Rewind a year or skip a year?
  • Read minds or see tomorrow?
  • Never lose your keys or never lose signal?
  • Free food forever or free travel forever?
  • A friend in every city or one lifelong crew?
  • Live by the ocean or in the mountains?
  • Sleep perfectly or eat perfectly?
  • Unlimited books or unlimited concerts?
  • More time or more energy?
  • Win small often or win big once?
  • Famous for a week or comfortable forever?
  • Always know the answer or always ask the best question?

Superpowers

  • Fly slowly or run incredibly fast?
  • Turn invisible or change your face?
  • Talk to animals or talk to plants?
  • Freeze time or rewind ten seconds?
  • Teleport to places you have been or fly anywhere?
  • Heal any injury or never get hurt?
  • Breathe underwater or survive any weather?
  • Control the weather or control your dreams?
  • Understand every language or never feel stage fright?
  • Perfect memory or perfect timing?
  • Shrink to pocket size or grow treetop tall?
  • Summon any snack or summon any outfit?

Silly stakes

  • Sneeze confetti or hiccup bubbles?
  • Wear oven mitts forever or flippers forever?
  • Always slightly damp or slightly itchy?
  • Only eat soup or only eat crackers?
  • Permanent bedhead or permanent sock tan?
  • Narrate every meal or applaud every entrance?
  • Only text in caps or only in emoji?
  • A tiny pet elephant or a giant pet hamster?
  • Be followed by seagulls or by pigeons?
  • Smell like popcorn or sound like a kazoo?
  • Have a theme song or a personal spotlight?
  • Hands for feet or feet for hands?

Hard choices

  • Lose every photo or lose every playlist?
  • Never be embarrassed or never be bored?
  • Know how people see you or never wonder?
  • Always be early or always be lucky?
  • Keep one memory or gain one new skill?
  • Be the funniest or the kindest in the room?
  • Your dream job or your dream schedule?
  • Never fail or never doubt yourself?
  • Say every thought or keep every secret?
  • Meet your younger self or your future self?
  • Start the trend or perfect it?
  • Be trusted or be needed?

Filming tips

  • Let the silence run for a beat before you answer. The pause is what makes the reaction readable.
  • Say the option you rejected as well as the one you picked, so the clip still makes sense on mute with captions.

More lists